|
Advertisement | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
J. Biol. Chem., Vol. 281, Issue 35, 25831-25840, September 1, 2006
Essential Residues in the C Terminus of the Bacteriophage T7 Gene 2.5 Single-stranded DNA-binding Protein*From the Department of Biological Chemistry and Molecular Pharmacology, Harvard Medical School, Boston, Massachusetts 02115
Received for publication, May 12, 2006 , and in revised form, June 19, 2006.
Gene 2.5 of bacteriophage T7 encodes a single-stranded DNA (ssDNA)-binding protein (gp2.5) that is an essential component of the phage replisome. Similar to other prokaryotic ssDNA-binding proteins, gp2.5 has an acidic C terminus that is involved in protein-protein interactions at the replication fork and in modulation of the ssDNA binding properties of the molecule. We have used genetic and biochemical approaches to identify residues critical for the function of the C terminus of gp2.5. The presence of an aromatic residue in the C-terminal position is essential for gp2.5 function. Deletion of the C-terminal residue, phenylalanine, is detrimental to its function, as is the substitution of this residue with non-aromatic amino acids. Placing the C-terminal phenylalanine in the penultimate position also results in loss of function. Moderate shortening of the length of the acidic portion of the C terminus is tolerated when the aromatic nature of the C-terminal residue is preserved. Gradual removal of the acidic C terminus of gp2.5 results in a higher affinity for ssDNA and a decreased ability to interact with T7 DNA polymerase/thioredoxin. The replacement of the charged residues in the C terminus with neutral amino acids abolishes gp2.5 function. Our data show that both the C-terminal aromatic residue and the overall acidic charge of the C terminus of gp2.5 are critical for its function.
Essentially all DNA replication systems require a cognate single-stranded DNA (ssDNA)4-binding protein. The ssDNA-binding protein of bacteriophage T7 is encoded by an essential gene of the phage, gene 2.5 (1). The gene 2.5 protein (gp2.5) contains 232 residues and appears to exist in solution as a dimer (2). gp2.5 binds to ssDNA with low micromolar affinity (2-4). It also facilitates homologous base-pairing between two DNA strands (5). gp2.5 is one of the four proteins that comprise the T7 replisome. The other three proteins are the T7 gene 5 DNA polymerase, its processivity factor, Escherichia coli thioredoxin (trx), and the multifunctional gene 4 helicase-primase.
One role of gp2.5 in vivo is almost certain to be to remove secondary structures in ssDNA that are known to impede the progress of the otherwise processive T7 DNA polymerase/thioredoxin (T7 DNA pol/trx) complex (2). However, the host ssDNA-binding protein, E. coli SSB protein, is equally effective in accomplishing this role (6). The essential nature of gp2.5 protein may rather be related to its known physical interactions with the T7 DNA pol/trx and the T7 gene 4 helicase-primase (7, 8). Biochemical manifestations of these interactions are a slight stimulation of T7 DNA pol/trx activity on ssDNA templates and an increase in the utilization of primase recognition sites and the efficiency with which the primers are extended by T7 DNA pol/trx (24).
The crystal structure of a gp2.5 lacking the C-terminal 26 amino acids (gp2.5
gp2.5 has an acidic C terminus, in which 15 of 21 residues have acidic side chains (Fig. 1). The presence of such an acidic C terminus is a conserved feature of all prokaryotic ssDNA-binding proteins despite the limited sequence homology (6, 11). The removal of the acidic C termini of these proteins is lethal and results in a higher affinity of the protein for ssDNA (12-15). In addition, protein-protein interactions have been mapped to the C termini of the T4 gene 32 ssDNA-binding protein and E. coli SSB protein (13, 16, 17). These C-terminal residues of T7 gp2.5 also define an important segment of gp2.5 because deletion of the sequence encoding these residues is lethal (7). The resulting protein, T7 gp2.5
Unfortunately, the only available structure of gp2.5 protein is that of T7 gp2.5 Identification of the specific role of gp2.5 at the replication fork is elusive. Its multiple interactions with DNA and the other replication proteins have been difficult to dissect. In the present study we have identified critical determinants within the C terminus for gp2.5 function in vivo and in vitro. Not only is the acidic nature of the fragment important but surprisingly an aromatic residue at the C-terminal position is critical for a functional protein. In the accompanying article we show likewise that both of these chemical requirements must be manifested in the C terminus of the gene 4 helicase-primase (Lee et al., Ref. 33). Not surprisingly, the C terminus of gene 4 protein likewise physically interacts with the highly basic thioredoxin binding domain of T7 DNA pol/trx (19).
Bacterial Strains and PhagesE. coli DH5 was used in all cloning procedures. E. coli MRI 80 (22) and E. coli C600 were used for in vivo DNA complementation and DNA synthesis assays. E. coli BL21(DE3)pLysS (Novagen) was used for protein expression. Wild-type T7 and T7 2.5 phages were previously described (1).
Plasmids and OligonucleotidesThe parent plasmids encoding native and His-tagged versions of wild-type gp2.5 and gp2.5 Construction of Plasmids Encoding Altered gp2.5 Proteins Alterations of the sequence encoding wild-type gp2.5 were generated by PCR. All oligonucleotides used for mutagenesis contained a BamHI restriction site immediately following the stop codon of gene 2.5. An oligonucleotide encompassing nucleotides 256-287 from the gp2.5 sequence was used as a reverse primer. The generated PCR product was digested with BamHI and MluI restriction enzymes and inserted into BamHI/MluI-digested pET17bgp2.5-wt vector. The constructs expressing His-tagged versions of altered gp2.5 proteins were generated by subcloning NdeI-BamHI gp2.5-containing fragments from the corresponding pET17b constructs into pET19bPPS vector (3). The sequence of all constructs was confirmed by sequencing. Gene Expression and Protein PurificationNative and histidine-tagged gp2.5 variants were purified from BL21(DE3)pLysS cells overexpressing their genes as previously described (3). T7 DNA pol/trx was purified as previously described (23).
In Vivo Complementation AssayTo test the ability of the gp2.5 variants to support the growth of T7 phage lacking gene 2.5 (T7
In Vivo DNA SynthesisE. coli MRI 80 cells were transformed with each plasmid of interest and infected with T7 ssDNA Gel Shift Assay5'-32P-End-labeled oligodeoxynucleotides of different length were used as a substrate to compare the ssDNA binding abilities of wild-type and altered gp2.5 proteins. The 15-µl reactions included 0.3 nM ssDNA substrate, 10 mM MgCl2, 5 mM DTT, 50 mM KCl, 10% glycerol, 0.01% bromphenol blue, and various concentrations gp2.5 variants diluted in a buffer containing 20 mM Tris (pH 7.5), 5 mM DTT, and 500 µg/ml bovine serum albumin. Reactions were incubated on ice for 10 min. Bound and free DNA species were resolved on a 10% TBE Ready Gel (Bio-Rad) using 0.5x Tris/glycine buffer (12.5 mM Tris base, 95 mM glycine, and 0.5 mM EDTA). Gels were run at 150 V at 4 °C until bromphenol blue reached two-thirds of the gel length. The gels were dried, exposed to a Fujix PhosphorImager plate, and the radioactivity was measured using Image-Quant software.
Surface Plasmon Resonance (SPR) AnalysisSPR was performed using a Biacore 3000 instrument. Wild-type and genetically altered gp2.5 variants (150 response units (RU)) were immobilized on a CM-5 (carboxymethyl-5) chip using EDC/NHS chemistry. The immobilization was performed at a flow rate of 40 µl/min in 10 mM sodium acetate, pH 5.0, except for the gp2.5
gp2.5 Stimulation of Strand Displacement DNA Synthesis The reaction contained 4 nM M13 template DNA, 0.3 mM of all four dNTPs (0.1 µCi of [
In Vivo Analysis of Alterations in the C Terminus of gp2.5 To determine the relative importance of the individual residues within the essential C terminus of the T7 gene 2.5 protein we have carried out extensive in vitro mutagenesis. As shown on Fig. 1A the acidic C terminus of gp2.5 contains 21 amino acids of which 15 have acidic side chain (8 glutamate (E) residues and 7 aspartate (D) residues). These acidic residues occur in blocks of varying lengths, separated mainly by non-polar amino acids such as alanine, serine, and glycine known to be associated with flexibility of the polypeptide chain. The C terminus ends with the aromatic residue phenylalanine (F) that by virtue of its free carboxyl group adds another negative charge. Fig. 1 summarizes all of the modifications of the C terminus used in the present study. Table 1 summarizes the ability of these same altered genes to complement the growth of T7 phage lacking gene 2.5. These constructs will be cited at the appropriate point in the text.
The C-terminal Phenylalanine Is Essential for the Function of Gene 2.5 ProteinIn earlier studies we have shown that gp2.5 proteins lacking the entire C terminus (gp2.5 21 and gp2.5 26) cannot complement for the growth of T7 phage lacking gene 2.5, T7 2.5 (3, 8). Inasmuch as we had attributed this phenotype to the removal of the acidic residues we were surprised to find that deletion of the C-terminal phenylalanine is as detrimental as deletion of the all C-terminal 26 residues (Table 1, A). In this initial experiment deletion mutants were constructed to progressively remove the charged residues by setting the boundaries of the deletions according to the positions of non-acidic residues. Thus gp2.5 1 removes the C-terminal phenylalanine, gp2.5 6 removes 6 residues, gp 17 removes 17 residues, and gp 26 eliminates the entire C terminus of 26 residues (Fig. 1A). To eliminate possible effects of overexpression of gene 2.5 variants from the strong T7 promoter in the pET17b vector used for cloning, all complementation experiments were performed in E. coli strains maintaining either high (DH5 ) or low (MRI 80) plasmid copy number. As shown in Table 1, gp2.5 1 lacking the C-terminal phenylalanine could not complement for the growth of T7 2.5. Not surprisingly, in view of the absence of the phenylalanine in the remaining deletion mutants, none of the other deletion mutants were able to complement for growth.
To determine if the inability of these deletion mutants to complement T7 2.5 arose from a defect in DNA synthesis, we measured the incorporation of [3H]thymidine into DNA after T7 2.5 infection of cells harboring the altered gene 2.5 (Fig. 2). When wild-type gp2.5 is overexpressed from a plasmid, DNA synthesis peaks at 35 min after phage infection. Little, if any, DNA synthesis occurred in cells infected with each of the deletion mutants. gp2.5 1 is equally as defective as is gp2.5 26 (Fig. 2B).
An Aromatic Residue at the C Terminus of Gene 2.5 Protein Is Critical for FunctionThe inability of gene 2.5 protein lacking its C-terminal phenylalanine to function in vivo could reflect a requirement for a specific length of the acidic C terminus or a requirement for a terminal residue of a specific chemical nature. To examine the former possibility we generated a series of gene 2.5 proteins in which internal residues were deleted from the C terminus but preserving the C-terminal phenylalanine (Fig. 1B). gp2.5 1F lacks the aspartic acid normally present adjacent to the phenylalanine. gp2.5 6F and gp2.5 17F lack the same acidic residues as gp2.5 6 and gp2.5 17, whereas preserving the C-terminal phenylalanine. gp2.5 1F and gp2.5 6F complemented for the growth of T7 2.5 phage almost as well as did wild-type gp2.5 (Table 1). The in vivo DNA synthesis assay showed that gp2.5 1F and gp2.5 6F retain 70 and 30%, respectively, of wild type ability to synthesize DNA (Fig. 2B). The more extensive deletion, gp2.5 17, that removes a major portion of the negative charge of the C terminus is unable to complement regardless of presence or absence of C-terminal phenylalanine. We also shortened and lengthened the distance of the C-terminal phenylalanine from the OB-fold harboring the ssDNA binding site by inserting (gp2.5Ins206(WFRA)207) or deleting (gp2.5 207-210) four amino acids just before the beginning of the acidic C terminus at position 207. These altered gene 2.5 proteins having an intact C terminus functioned normally (Table 1, B and Fig. 2A). The finding that up to six residues can be deleted from the C terminus without a deleterious effect suggests strongly that a simple shortening of the fragment does not explain the defect arising from the deletion of the phenylalanine.
Is the location of the phenylalanine as the C-terminal amino acid important or is there simply a requirement for a phenylalanine near the C terminus? To address this question we switched the two C-terminal residues such that aspartic acid is now the C-terminal residue and phenylalanine is adjacent as second residue (gp2. 5InsF231
To gain insight into the properties of phenylalanine that gives rise to its essential role we constructed a series of gene 2.5 proteins in which various amino acids replaced the C-terminal phenylalanine (Fig. 1D). As seen in Table 1, D of the six amino acid substitutions only those proteins in which tyrosine (gp2.5-F232Y) and tryptophan (gp2.5-F232W) occupied the C-terminal position could function in vivo. gp2.5-F232Y and gp2.5F232W retain
Contribution of Acidic ResiduesThe essential nature of the phenylalanine does not rule out an equally important role for the acidic properties of the C terminus. The interaction between gp2.5 and T7 DNA pol/trx is salt-sensitive, suggesting involvement of charged residues (8). Indeed, recent studies on the binding of gp2.5 to the T7 DNA pol/trx show that at least a part of that interaction is mediated by charged residues in the thioredoxin-binding domain of the DNA polymerase (19). The loss of function for gp2.5
To separate the contribution of charge from that of length of the acidic C terminus we have maintained the length of the C terminus while varying the acidic content. The replacement of all acidic residues with uncharged residues, i.e. glutamate with glutamine and aspartate with asparagines (Fig. 1E), resulted in a nonfunctional protein (Table 1, E). We also replaced the C-terminal 17 residues of gp2.5 with the 17 C-terminal residues of the T7 gene 4 helicase-primase. The latter protein also has an acidic C terminus with a C-terminal phenylalanine (see Ref. 33 and Fig. 1E). However, the C-terminal tail of gene 4 protein is not as acidic as that of gp2.5, having five less acidic residues (Fig. 1E). This chimeric protein retained function as judged by its ability to complement the growth of T7
Effect of the C-terminal Phenylalanine and Charge on Biochemical Properties of gp2.5In an attempt to identify the biochemical roles of the the C-terminal phenylalanine and the acidic residues in the C terminus, we overexpressed and purified a subset of the altered proteins described above. In this section we present the biochemical properties of these proteins. The gene 2.5 proteins are designated as gp2.5
Affinity for ssDNAThe affinity of the gp2.5 for ssDNA was examined using a gel-shift mobility assay. In earlier studies we used either a 39- or 70-nt oligonucleotide, whose lengths should contain 5 and 10 binding sites, respectively (3, 4, 18). In those studies both low and high mobility protein-DNA complexes were observed probably corresponding to heterogeneity in the number of protein molecules bound to the oligonucleotides. In order to simplify the interpretation of the data we have determined the minimal length of oligonucleotide suitable for gel-shift assays. Using oligonucleotides ranging from 4 to 70 nucleotides we examined the binding of wild-type gp2.5 using the gel-shift assay described under "Experimental Procedures" (Fig. 3). Four nucleotides were not sufficient for binding and only minimal binding occurs with oligonucleotides of 7 and 17 nucleotides as judged by the presence of smeary bands indicative of unstable binding. The shortest oligonucleotide that gave stable complex was the 23-mer. We also examined the binding of gp2.5 26 lacking the entire C terminus since previous studies had shown this altered protein to bind more tightly to ssDNA (4, 18). As shown in Fig. 3, the binding curve is essentially the same as that obtained with wild-type protein except that the curve is shifted left with significant binding now observed with the 17-mer. On the basis of these experiments we have used the 23-mer oligonucleotide in the gel-shift assays described here. With this oligonucleotide wild-type gp2.5 bound with KD of 3 µM (Fig. 4). The KD values calculated should be considered apparent KD values rather than absolute KD values because the oligonucleotide used in the mobility shift assay contains more than one binding site. The C-terminal phenylalanine, essential for T7 function in vivo, does not appear to be involved in binding of the protein to ssDNA. Fig. 5A plots the reciprocal value of the KD (1/KD)so that the higher the bar, the higher the affinity of the protein for ssDNA. None of the amino acid substitutions for phenylalanine had any significant effect on the KD for ssDNA nor did the switch of phenylalanine with its adjacent aspartic acid.
On the other hand, the negative charge of the C terminus is important in ssDNA binding. In the experiment shown on Fig. 5B progressive deletions were made in the C terminus resulting in a progressive loss of acidic residues. The removal of one to six residues had almost no effect on the ssDNA binding affinity (3 to 2.5 µM). The removal of 17 residues and hence 13 acidic residues results in a 30-fold increase in the affinity for the 23-mer oligonucleotide and the removal of all acidic residues (gp2.5
Both the C-terminal Phenylalanine and the Acidic Residues Are Required for gp2.5 Interactions with T7 DNA pol/trxIt has been shown previously that T7 DNA pol/trx complex physically interacts with gp2.5. The interaction between gp2.5 and T7 DNA pol/trx complex is salt-sensitive (8). Furthermore, a deletion of the acidic C terminus (gp2.5 26) abolishes this interaction (8). Our results shown above raise the possibility that the presence of the C-terminal phenylalanine is an important determinant for the gp2.5 interaction with T7 DNA pol/trx. This possibility is especially interesting because the acidic termini of both gp2.5 and gene 4 helicase-primase contact T7 DNA pol/trx complex within the unique segment of the gene 5 T7 DNA polymerase to which thioredoxin binds (19). The acidic C termini of both gp2.5 and gene 4 protein have a C-terminal phenylalanine. However, as pointed out above, the C terminus of gp2.5 is more acidic than that of gene 4 protein. The altered gene 2.5 proteins used in the present study allow us to evaluate the relative contributions of the C-terminal residue and the charge of the C terminus on these interactions. We have used SPR to measure the interactions of the gp2.5 proteins with T7 DNA pol/trx. In this study wild-type gp2.5 as well as the genetically altered gp2.5 proteins were immobilized on CM5 chips as described under "Experimental Procedures." Increasing concentrations of T7 DNA pol/trx were then flowed over the gp2.5 immobilized on the chip (Fig. 6A). The relevant binding constants were calculated using steady-state kinetics. Fig. 6B shows the binding curve used to calculate the KD of 2.4 µM for the interaction of wild-type gp2.5 with T7 DNA pol/trx. The observed KD is consistent with previously reported KD for this interaction as determined by SPR experiments (3, 4, 18) or fluorescence anisotropy (8). A higher affinity (KD of 0.13 µM) was measured for the interaction of wild-type gp2.5 with a T7 DNA pol/trx complex that was reconstituted from individually purified gene 5 protein and thioredoxin (19).
The presence of an aromatic residue at the C terminus of gp2.5 is essential for its interaction with T7 DNA pol/trx. The apparent association constants (1/KD) of selected altered proteins are presented on Fig. 7. The removal of the phenylalanine (gp2.5
The presence of a negative charge in the C terminus is also important for binding of gp2.5 to T7 DNA pol/trx. Thus gp2.5 6F lacking 4 acidic residues but retaining the C-terminal phenylalanine binds 10-fold less well as is the case for the chimeric gp2.5 bearing the C terminus of gene 4 protein (gp2.5-C-term-gp4). This latter protein has five less acidic residues in a C terminus of identical length and with a C-terminal phenylalanine. As expected gp2.5 26 displayed no detectable interaction with T7 DNA pol/trx. Strand Displacement ActivityT7 DNA pol/trx and gene 4 helicase-primase are able to catalyze a strand displacement DNA synthesis on duplex DNA. Interestingly, E. coli SSB protein enables the T7 DNA pol/trx to catalyze strand displacement activity in the absence of helicase, whereas wild-type gp2.5 does not. However, we recently described a genetically altered gp2.5, gp2.5F232L, that could also enable T7 DNA pol/trx to catalyze strand displacement synthesis (18). This altered gp2.5 in which the C-terminal phenylalanine had been replaced by leucine came from a screen for essential amino acid residues in gp2.5. In view of this finding we have examined the ability of all altered gp2.5 proteins generated in this work to support strand displacement DNA synthesis by T7 DNA pol/trx. In the assays shown in Fig. 8 equal amounts of wild type and mutant gp2.5 variants were incubated at 37 °C for 20 min with a template consisting of a 5' radioactively labeled 24-mer annealed to M13 ssDNA. Whereas it is clear that in the positive control reaction (Fig. 8, lane 16) with E. coli SSB protein strand displacement DNA synthesis is stimulated as judged by the appearance of high molecular weight products (marked with vertical bracket), none of the gp2.5 variants enables T7 DNA pol/trx to catalyze strand displacement DNA synthesis.
The C-terminal region of gp2.5 has been previously identified (8, 19) as a mediator for its interactions with the T7 DNA pol/trx complex. In the current study we have carried out extensive genetic and biochemical analyses to identify critical determinants for the function of the C terminus of gp2.5. We find that both the negative charge of the C terminus and the aromatic nature of the C-terminal residue are critical for T7 growth in vivo and for the interaction of gp2.5 with T7 DNA pol/trx in vitro. Of these two critical determinants the most surprising and perhaps the most important is the requirement for an aromatic C-terminal residue. Only the substitution of tryptophan or tyrosine for the C-terminal phenylalanine preserves the function of gp2.5 in vivo, a finding that correlates with the ability of these aromatic residues to also preserve the interaction of gp2.5 with T7 DNA pol/trx. Furthermore, the position of the aromatic residue as the C-terminal amino acid is also critical. Positioning the phenylalanine penultimate to the C-terminal residue is not sufficient for the protein to function in vivo or to interact with T7 DNA pol/trx in vitro. Although the negative charge of the C-terminal tail of gp2.5 is clearly important, a moderate reduction in charge is tolerated as long as an aromatic residue is present as the C-terminal residue. Decreasing the charge of the C-terminal tail affects DNA binding as well, whereas the C-terminal phenylalanine is only critical for the interaction of gp2.5 with T7 DNA pol/trx. Similarities of T7 gp2.5 with Other Prokaryotic ssDNA-binding ProteinsAcidic C termini and OB folds are features shared by all prokaryotic ssDNA-binding proteins thus far characterized. However, the importance of the C-terminal residue has not previously been observed. We have carried out a sequence homology search with each of the three well characterized prokaryotic ssDNA-binding proteins, E. coli SSB protein, T4 gene 32 protein (gp32), and T7 gp2.5. These three proteins, although having structural similarities, share minimal sequence homology. The C-terminal phenylalanine is well conserved among gp2.5 homologs as well as E. coli SSB protein homologs. In contrast, all gp32 homologs have leucine or isoleucine at the C-terminal position. A striking feature of the latter group is the presence of block(s) of serine within the C-terminal acidic tail (7 residues for gp32). All gp2.5 homologs have aspartate in the penultimate position, whereas all E. coli SSB protein homologs have proline. Interestingly, the replacement of the proline with serine results in a temperature sensitive phenotype (24). In the accompanying paper (33), we show that the T7 gene 4 helicase-primase also has a functionally important C-terminal phenylalanine. Consequently, we carried out a similar sequence analysis for all T7 gene 4 protein homologs. All T7-like phages encode a helicase-primase fusion protein with an acidic C terminus having phenylalanine as the C-terminal residue and aspartate in the penultimate position. In contrast, T4-like phages and E. coli encode separate helicase and primase proteins, neither of which possess acidic C termini. Thus, T7 whose replisome has only four proteins may have evolved a unique strategy for protein-protein interactions within the functional replisome.
Chimeric protein, in which the C terminus of gp2.5 was replaced with the C terminus of E. coli SSB protein was found to be functional. This result is not surprising because the C terminus of E. coli SSB protein has a similar length, charge distribution and a C-terminal phenylalanine. Chimeric protein, in which the C terminus of gp2.5 was replaced with the C terminus of phage T4 gp32 is partially functional, although its burst size is reduced Modulation of the ssDNA Binding Properties of gp2.5 by the C Terminus gp2.5 binds ssDNA with micromolar affinity in a nonspecific manner. Similar to other ssDNA-binding proteins, it is thought that ssDNA binds within the cleft of the oligonucleotide/oligosaccharide binding fold (OB-fold) via contacts with positively charged and aromatic residues (10). Proteolytic fragments of gp32 of phage T4 and E. coli SSB protein, lacking the C-terminal portions of these proteins were reported to bind ssDNA with higher affinity than the full-length protein (12-14,25). A similar phenomenon has been described for HMG (High Mobility Group) proteins found in chromatin (26). HMG proteins bind dsDNA nonspecifically and are abundant and well conserved among eukaryotes. They facilitate the assembly of nucleoprotein complexes within the chromatin. Interestingly, HMG proteins have long negatively charged C termini, that contact the DNA binding region of the proteins. Similarly to prokaryotic ssDNA-binding proteins, the removal of the acidic C terminus results in higher affinity for ssDNA. In contrast, the phosphorylation of the C terminus, which increases the negative charge, results in lower affinity for DNA. It appears that the modulation of the DNA binding activity by a flexible acidic tail is not unique to prokaryotic ssDNA-binding proteins but rather associated with proteins exhibiting nonspecific DNA binding. The C-terminal phenylalanine does not play a role in the modulation of the ssDNA binding properties of gp2.5. Significance of Unstructured C Terminus and an Aromatic C-terminal Residue in Protein-Protein InteractionsNot only do both gp2.5 and gp4 helicase-primase have acidic C termini and a C-terminal phenylalanine but their C termini are also thought to be unstructured. The C terminus of gp4 is disordered as seen by x-ray (27, 28) and the presence of the C terminus of gp2.5 prevented crystallization (10), suggesting that these regions are highly flexible. NMR experiments have revealed that peptides corresponding to the acidic C terminus of gp2.5 and gp4 helicase-primase are unstructured in solution.5 Recently, it was reported that the C terminus of E. coli SSB protein is unstructured even when the protein is in complex with DNA (29).
Unstructured flexible regions are not unique for ssDNA-binding proteins. It is generally thought that regions which are involved in protein-protein interactions with multiple partners are flexible and unstructured in order to accommodate different requirements of the interacting partner. For example, histones have unstructured N termini and C termini that are known to interact with multiple proteins. Similarly, when the C terminus of phage T4 gp32, which is also unstructured, was immobilized on an affinity column multiple members of replication and recombinational pathways, were found to bind the column (12).
An interesting example of a protein with flexible acidic C terminus ending with a C-terminal phenylalanine is Strad Possible Mechanistic Role of the C Terminus of gp2.5 Whereas the mechanistic details about the role of the flexible acidic C terminus and the C-terminal phenylalanine of gp2.5 protein remain to be understood, it is clear that gp2.5 plays a central role at the T7 replication fork. It has been hypothesized previously, that in absence of DNA the C terminus of gp2.5 occupies the DNA binding cleft of the protein (10). Because such interaction is likely to be weak, the C-terminal tail may "oscillate" between bound and free position, being easily displaced when ssDNA is present. According to this model, when the C terminus is shortened its interactions with the DNA-binding cleft is weakened. Correspondingly, less energy is required for the C terminus to be displaced from the cleft by ssDNA, thus explaining the increased binding affinity for ssDNA observed with the C-terminal deletion mutants of gp2.5. A similar model has been proposed previously to explain the ssDNA-binding properties of phage T4 gp32 and its proteolytic fragments (reviewed in Ref. 6). One can visualize the C terminus as a mimic of ssDNA. The high acidic content resembles the negatively charged phosphate backbone of DNA, whereas the C-terminal phenylalanine and the tryptophan in position 216 resemble the aromatic moiety of the bases. In the absence of ssDNA the negatively charged C terminus binds in the DNA binding cleft. In addition to a role of the C terminus of gp2.5 in binding to T7 DNA pol/trx, its binding to the positively charged DNA binding cleft could be a simple mechanism to protect the binding site from random interaction with negatively charged surfaces of other molecules in the cell and thus ensure fast and efficient coverage of arising ssDNA. The C terminus is a good candidate for a molecular switch, coordinating the ssDNA binding of gp2.5 and its involvement in protein-protein interactions. One possible scenario predicts that after the DNA binding cleft is occupied, the C terminus is displaced and becomes readily available for contacts with other proteins. If the C terminus-mediated interaction results in stable complex this complex can serve as a platform for recruitment of multiprotein complexes such as the replisome, the recombination machinery or DNA repair machinery. ssDNA-binding proteins, including the T7 gp2.5, have been shown to play role in all of the above processes involving DNA transactions. Such a mechanism employing a single surface as a target of multiple interacting partners has been proposed for hRPA32, a subunit of the human SSB protein. Proteins involved in 3 different repair pathways bind the same surface of hRPA32 and promote the recruitment and the assembly of the repair complex relevant to the type of the DNA damage (32). It is striking that all T7-like phages encode a helicase-primase fusion protein and ssDNA-binding protein, both of which have an acidic C terminus and a C-terminal phenylalanine. In addition, the C termini of gp2.5 and gp4 contact T7 DNA polymerase at the same surface, the thioredoxin binding domain (19). Our working model postulates that the negatively charged C termini make initial contact with gp5 via electrostatic interactions with the positively charged residues within the trx binding loop. Most likely, the role of the phenylalanine is to "fine-tune" or "validate" the electrostatic interaction. Obviously, neither the acidic charge nor the phenylalanine could ensure the specificity of the T7 DNA pol/trx interaction with gp2.5 and gp4 helicase-primase. It is tempting to speculate that the acidic flexible tail in combination with the C-terminal aromatic residue, leads to a weak initial binding to T7 DNA pol/trx complex. The length of the negatively charged region and the net weight of the charge may then guide the polymerase toward a conformational change facilitating second site interaction, outside the boundaries of the acidic C terminus. A two-site interaction is supported by the fact that the overall affinity of T7 DNA pol/trx interactions with gp2.5 and gp4 helicase-primase is different, despite the similarities in their acidic C termini. In addition, while the acidic C terminus of gp2.5 is essential for the interaction with T7 DNA pol/trx in both the presence and absence of DNA, the acidic C terminus of gp4 helicase-primase is essential only in the absence of DNA and dispensable in the presence of a primer/template (19). The parallel between the mode of gp2.5 and gp4 helicase-primase interactions with T7 DNA pol/trx complex is intriguing and points to a well regulated network of dynamic protein-protein interactions within the phage T7 replisome.
* This work was supported by United States Public Health Services Grant GM 54397 and by United States Department of Energy Grant DE-FG02-96ER62251. The costs of publication of this article were defrayed in part by the payment of page charges. This article must therefore be hereby marked "advertisement" in accordance with 18 U.S.C. Section 1734 solely to indicate this fact.
1 Funded by National Institutes of Health Postdoctoral Fellowships ST32A107245-20 and F32GM72305.
2 Both authors contributed equally to the work. 3 To whom correspondence should be addressed: Dept. of Biological Chemistry and Molecular Pharmacology, Harvard Medical School, 240 Longwood Ave., Boston, MA 02115. Tel.: 617-432-1864; Fax: 617-432-3362; E-mail: ccr{at}hms.harvard.edu.
4 The abbreviations used are: ssDNA, single-stranded DNA; wt, wild-type; trx, thioredoxin; SSB protein, single-stranded DNA-binding protein; hRPA, human replication protein A; cpm, counts per minute; DTT, dithiothreitol; SPR, surface plasmon resonance; RU, response units.
5 B. Marintcheva, A. Marintchev, G. Wagner, and C. Richardson, unpublished data.
We thank Steven Moskowitz (Advanced Medical Graphics, Boston) for help with figure preparation.
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||